Best Pepper Varieties for Pennsylvania

This page contains affiliate links — we may earn a small commission on purchases at no extra cost to you.

Peppers are more demanding than tomatoes in Pennsylvania — they need warmer soil, a longer indoor head start, and enough season length to fully ripen. In return, a well-chosen variety delivers dozens of fruits per plant with less disease pressure than tomatoes. The key is matching variety to zone.

This guide covers the best sweet peppers, hot peppers, and specialty types for Pennsylvania — with days to maturity, PA zone recommendations, and honest notes on what actually produces well across our five hardiness zones.

PA Pepper Season Calendar

Quick Reference by Zone

Best Sweet Peppers for Pennsylvania

Carmen — Best All-PA Sweet Pepper

Carmen is the top-performing sweet pepper for Pennsylvania across all five hardiness zones. It’s an Italian bull’s horn type — long, tapered, ripening from green to deep red — that matures in just 60 days. Carmen is an All-America Selections winner, and it earned that recognition for good reason: it tolerates cooler summers better than large-fruited bells, sets fruit prolifically, and ripens reliably even in the shorter-season zones where standard bells struggle.

The flavor is sweet and rich whether harvested green or red. Plants are productive enough that three plants will keep a household supplied all summer. Thin walls mean no extended heat required to develop fully — a real advantage in Zone 5 and 6a.

Lipstick — Fastest Sweet Pepper

Lipstick is a pimento-type pepper maturing in just 53 days — the fastest reliable sweet pepper for PA. It’s the go-to choice for Zone 5a mountain growers and anyone who wants ripe colored fruit as early as possible. The fruit is small (3–4 inches), blocky, and turns from pale green to bright red with a thick, sweet flesh. Cold-set ability is excellent — it will set fruit even when nights dip briefly into the low 50s, where bell peppers drop blossoms entirely.

King of the North — Best Bell for Short Seasons

If you want bell peppers in Zones 5a–6a, King of the North is the only bell that consistently performs. It matures in 67 days, sets fruit in cool conditions that stall standard California Wonder-type bells, and produces classic blocky green-to-red bells that taste like what you’d buy at the store. It won’t match the thick-walled perfection of a Zone 7a bell, but it delivers real bell peppers in zones where others fail.

Cubanelle (Italian Frying Pepper)

Cubanelle is a pale yellow-green, thin-walled frying pepper that matures at 65–70 days. The thin walls are its key advantage — it doesn’t need the extended heat that thick-walled bells require to develop fully. It’s prolific, mild-sweet, and excellent roasted, sautéed, or pickled. Zone 5 gardeners who want a productive, forgiving sweet pepper and don’t need classic bell shape often find Cubanelle outperforms everything else they try.

Shishito — High-Yield Specialty

Shishito is a Japanese frying pepper maturing in 55–60 days with very high yield per plant. Harvest green (the preferred stage) and blister in a hot pan with oil and salt. About one in ten peppers will be unexpectedly spicy — part of the appeal. Productive across all PA zones, handles heat better than many thin-walled types, and popular with anyone who grows for farmers markets or entertaining.

Sweet Pepper Comparison Table

Best Hot Peppers for Pennsylvania

Early Jalapeño — Best All-Zone Hot Pepper

Early Jalapeño matures in 65 days — about 10–15 days faster than standard jalapeño varieties — and is the best hot pepper for PA growers in Zones 5a through 5b who need to hit the season window. Heat is moderate (2,500–8,000 SHU), the classic jalapeño profile that works for salsas, pickling, and fresh use. Prolific producer across all PA zones with no special coddling.

Hungarian Hot Wax — Highest-Yield PA Hot

Hungarian Hot Wax is arguably the most productive hot pepper you can grow in Pennsylvania. It matures in 65–70 days, produces enormous numbers of banana-shaped fruits (harvest yellow-to-orange; hotter at red), and — critically — sets fruit reliably even in cool weather. Heat runs 5,000–10,000 SHU — medium, well-distributed heat that works well pickled or fresh. It’s also one of the few hot peppers that shines in Zone 5b alongside the standards.

Cayenne Long Red — Best for Drying

If you dry peppers or make hot sauce, Cayenne Long Red at 70–75 days is the PA workhorse. It’s prolific, the fruits dry beautifully on or off the vine, and heat runs 30,000–50,000 SHU — enough heat to matter without being difficult to handle. Best in Zones 6a–7a where the slightly longer season lets it ripen and dry before hard frost.

Poblano (Ancho) — Best Mild Hot for Stuffing

Poblano matures in 75–80 days and produces large, dark green peppers ideal for chiles rellenos and roasting. Dried, they become ancho chiles. Heat is very mild (1,000–2,000 SHU) — more about flavor than burn. Best in Zones 6a–7a; the longer season requirement makes it risky in Zone 5. A standout specialty pepper for Pennsylvania cooks.

Habanero — Zone 6b–7a Only

Habanero needs 90–100 days of warm weather — that’s the full productive season for much of PA. It’s only reliably successful in Zones 6b–7a, and even there you must start seeds in early February to have any margin. Heat runs 100,000–350,000 SHU. If you’re in Philadelphia or Lancaster County and love habaneros, grow them — but don’t attempt them in Zone 5 or 6a unless you have a high tunnel or season-extension setup.

Hot Pepper Comparison Table

Zone-by-Zone Variety Picks

Zone 5a (Mountains — Shortest Season)

Stick to varieties under 65 days. Lipstick (53d) and Carmen (60d) are your sweet pepper foundation. Shishito (55–60d) is reliable for specialty use. For hot peppers, Early Jalapeño (65d) is the ceiling — anything slower risks frost before harvest. Use every season-extension tool available: row cover at transplant, black plastic mulch for soil warmth, raised beds.

Zone 5b (Scranton, Erie)

Same short-season discipline, but Hungarian Hot Wax opens up as a viable hot pepper alongside Early Jalapeño. Carmen and Lipstick remain the best sweets. Avoid standard bells — King of the North is the only bell worth attempting, and even then it’s risky in a cool summer.

Zone 6a (Pittsburgh, Harrisburg, Allentown)

The variety range expands significantly. Cubanelle joins Carmen as a top sweet. Cayenne Long Red and Serrano become viable hot peppers. King of the North works as a bell. Poblano and Cayenne both ripen before frost in most years. Skip Habanero — the season is marginal and the risk isn’t worth it.

Zone 6b (Reading, York, Lancaster)

The most productive pepper zone in PA. California Wonder and other standard bells work. The full range of hot peppers through Cayenne is reliable. Habanero is marginal — attempt it with an early February seed start and row cover at transplant. Armenian or Jimmy Nardello open up for specialty sweet production.

Zone 7a (Philadelphia Area)

Grow anything. Habaneros are reliable with a February start. The full range of bells, sweets, and hots all perform well. The only challenge is blossom drop during July heat spikes above 90°F — expected and temporary, not a variety problem. Focus on heat tolerance and productivity rather than season length.

Season planning: Check our month-by-month Pennsylvania planting guide to keep your garden producing all year. Browse all Pennsylvania vegetable guides for companion planting ideas.

Frequently Asked Questions About Pepper Varieties in Pennsylvania